Manuscript submitted after decision started. . Give yourself the best chance to succeed! Now that you’ve submitted your academic manuscript to a journal or publisher, it can be easy to think that you are finished with your research process. If the authors submit a revised manuscript, the workflow is mostly the same as for the initial submission. Peer reviewers’ time is not wasted – reviewers don’t have to spend time evaluating and giving feedback for a manuscript of clearly inferior quality. A desk rejection, particularly at a journal like nature where there are a lot of submission, can definitely take more than a week. I have submitted a manuscript to a Nature journal (not *the* Nature though) and have been "Manuscript under consideration" for ten days - does anyone have any experience with this and then being desk rejected? Question: How do I check the status of my article? Answer: Once you have registered, you can check the status of your article at any time by logging into Author Services and visiting the "My Dashboard" section. The graphic below shows how a typical manuscript goes through the Editorial Manager system, along with some of the terms used to describe the manuscript’s status. Learn to decipher common manuscript status terms and track the progress of your submission effectively. Recently I submitted my work to a Nature sub-journal. At this stage, the editor has to choose an outcome for the paper. What happens to a manuscript after submission? How does the editor reach a decision? What is the editor’s role during peer review? We take a look into the editorial process at Nature Cancer. I sent the revised version, and the editor said he would let us know the decision after referee's recommendation. Some journals follow a slightly different production process whereby all articles for an issue are sent to a copyeditor en masse before the articles are sent to the typesetter. The manuscript shall be accepted as it is. Once you do submit, it’s likely that you’ll have questions about when your paper will be published. We oversee this process to e Once submitted to a journal, the manuscript travels around quite a bit and the manuscript status is followed using the manuscript number. Visit the IEEE Publication Portal to get started. After the manuscript is submitted, the editor-in-chief or the handling editor of the journal performs an initial assessment. In each stage, the status of a manuscript changes. We do, however, ask you to respect the following summaries of our policies: Format and style of main manuscript Format and style of supplementary material Preparation of figures Science Citation Style Information on manuscript types, including length constraints, can be found on our general information for authors page. I'll answer with a bit of bravado. After that it is showing decision started since last 30 days? what can be the reasons for such This article shows the editorial process after Submitting a manuscript to a journal. Stage 1: Initial quality check This stage includes checks on authorship, competing interests, ethics approval and plagiarism. Gain a clear understanding of the various stages your manuscript during the publication process. Once you’ve submitted your manuscript, it will be pre-checked, and then sent for review. Remember– what you do after you complete your initial submission This article shows the editorial process after Submitting a manuscript to a journal. it was under review for a month. A technical editor may scan the manuscript and the review comments to ensure that journal standards have been followed. 今天投必得就为大家先总结一下各种审稿状态的基本含义，揭开它们的神秘面纱！ 1. We answer questions about the review stage here. We submitted our manuscript on June 12th, and it went through two stages that day (Manuscript under submission -> Manuscript received). We oversee this process to e The manuscript shall be rejected. Submitted to Journal/New Submission 当投稿稿件上传结束后，显示的状态是Submitted to Journal或New Submission，这个状态即说明提交成功了。 2. Understanding this process is pivotal for academic researchers. The decision letter will specify a deadline for receipt of the revised manuscript and link via which the author should upload to the online submission system. All manuscripts submitted to us must be written in clear English so that readers (and reviewers) are able to understand the meaning of the article. ' What do these status changes mean? 1、Submitted to Journal：稿件上传结束后，会显示稿件状态为submitted to journal，该状态是自然形成的，无需处理。 2、Manuscript Received by Editorial Office：稿件已到编辑处，表明投稿成功。 如果投稿不符合标准，会返回，然后告诉哪里有问题。 在同一天里走完了Manuscript under submission->Manuscript received->Editor assigned->Manuscript under consideration，然后第二天->Editor Decision Started开始审稿人第二轮审稿。 因为这回修改的非常好，两周审稿人就全都回过来审稿意见了，然后大编辑给我们发了邮件： Editorial process General information Initial submission Transfers Guest Edited Collections Peer review Decision after review and revision Final submission and acceptance Appeals and Complaints Submission of Final Manuscript Files: After a paper or correspondence item is recommended for publication, the corresponding author will be contacted by the Editorial Office and given information on what is required for the Final Submission Package and a link for uploading the Final Submission Package. After a couple of days, its status changed to “with editor”. Editorial Process On this page: Summary of the editorial process | Online submission | Peer review | Post-acceptance | E-proofs Summary of the editorial process The author submits a manuscript and 在这一阶段，稿件状态通常显示为“Manuscript submitted（稿件已提交）”、“Manuscript under consideration（稿件正在考虑中）”或“Manuscript received（稿件已收到）”。 在审稿阶段，期刊编辑将稿件送交同行评审。 After several rounds of revision, when the revised manuscript was submitted, the status showed 'quality check started' - 'peer review' - 'decision started. These This guide is designed to help you understand the process that your manuscript will go though from the point that you submit it to one of the British Psychological Society’s journals up until the point when it is (hopefully) published. Find everything you need to publish and review in ACS journals: choosing the best journal, preparing your manuscript, the peer-review process, and more. Submit Your Article After checking that your article complies with the target journal’s submission guidelines, you are ready to submit. But there was no updates since then. About the editorial process: As there are many steps involved in the editorial process, this may in some cases take longer than you had anticipated. Appeals Some authors ask the editors to reconsider a rejection decision. Manuscript status can be a little bit confusing at times. We strongly advise you to ask a native-English-speaking colleague to check your manuscript before submission. It quickly went from "manuscript submitted" to "editor assigned" and "manuscript under consideration". See How do I send an email about my submission? I submitted a paper to one of Elsevier’s journals. I recently submitted a paper to a Nature journal. Since then it has been 2 months, but yet to receive the decision. These journals publish the reviewer comments and previous versions of the manuscript alongside the accepted paper. I submitted a manuscript to a Nature journal six days ago. How long does it take to give a decision after revision? Should I contact the editor to know about the update, if any? Thanks Along with the ease of online manuscript submission, researchers can also track the status of their manuscript, post-submission to the journal through various submission systems like Editorial Manager, ScholarOne, and EVISE. To contact the Editor, you must be the Corresponding Author. Once a manuscript enters the editorial system, it undergoes a structured evaluation before a final decision is reached. Also you have to assume people have been off for the holiday. Mar 26, 2020 · Confused by the status “Decision in Process” after your first round of peer review? Learn what this journal status means, how long it may take, and what it indicates about your manuscript’s progress toward acceptance or rejection. Once editors have evaluated manuscripts and read the referee reports submitted during the peer review process, if applicable, it is time to register an editorial decision. How long time should we wait for editor decision on a manuscript? What should we do if there is no decision/communication even after more than 1 year Hello. It is also the beginning of a complex publication process in which a manuscript goes through different stages. Following peer review, if a manuscript is accepted, it then undergoes proof development and a review process prior to publication. Nov 20, 2025 · The submission status “Editor Decision Started” often triggers anxiety for authors, as it signals the end of the long assessment period and the imminent arrival of a verdict on their research. Not following guidelines can result in delayed processing of your submission, rejection without review, or errors in your published article. "The Nature journals support the posting of submitted manuscripts on community preprint servers such as arXiv and bioRxiv. A quick decision for authors – if the manuscript clearly lies outside the scope of the journal, then a rapid rejection allows the author to submit their article to another journal more quickly. Types of peer review BMJ mainly operates the following types of peer review: Open peer review: Reviewer and author are known to each other. Now (4 days after the initial submission), it is now under the status of "Editorial Decision Started". Once a manuscript is submitted to a journal, it goes through an initial screening process which involves a preliminary review by the journal editor. At the first submission, the status has been updated at each step (ex. This document provides an outline of the editorial process involved in publishing a scientific paper (Article) in Nature, and describes how manuscripts are handled by editors between submission Jan 8, 2016 · If you have submitted your manuscript to an Editorial Manager journal but you have not yet received a final decision, you can check its status online. I have submitted a manuscript in (nature) Scientific report journal. Contents Overview of stages when publishing a manuscriptThe meaning After your editor submits a decision on your manuscript, the journal may review it before formally processing the decision and sending it on to you. I analyzed that this is equivalent to the manuscript being sent to the chief editor for review. Read on to know the possible outcomes and what they mean for you as the author. But now after about ten days from the submission date, it changed to “Decision in Pro Your revised manuscript should be submitted using the link provided in the decision email, and not as a new manuscript. “with referees”), so I’m worried about the unchanged status of this resubmission. With editor 这个阶段实质上包括技术审查和寻找 In this article, an experienced journal editor explains the sequence of events that lead from peer review to editorial decision making: how the AE evaluates the completed reviews and comes to a decision on whether to accept the manuscript, request revisions, or reject it. I'm a postdoc working in the field of cancer genomics. Submitting a manuscript to an academic journal is a big step. Submitting your manuscript to an MDPI journal involves hours of research, drafting, and formatting, before finally finishing with a paper that you’re happy with and ready to publish. A decision requires further reviews. Before discussing what happens after a manuscript is submitted, we would like to offer a few suggestions for final preparation of a submission that can increase how quickly the manuscript can be evaluated and a final decision delivered to the authors. When you have submitted your manuscript successfully the next step is peer review. ' What could this mean? To ensure that the submission process is as smooth as possible for our authors, we've assembled a list of commonly asked questions. I witnessed it many times that the "decision in process" status did not change for weeks. The manuscript needs to be revised by the authors before it can possibly be accepted. Why is that? Office hours of the editor-in-chief? As for my understanding, many editors-in-chief are full-time professionals hired by the respective journals. Editorial manager 中显示的状态词如下表所示。每一个状态都表示审稿过程的特定阶段，通常以一定的顺序发生，但是一篇稿件的处理可以跳过一个阶段，或者返回到更早的阶段，这取决于编辑的操作。每本期刊都可以自定义状态术语措辞，但是相同的状态阶段名词适用于使用 Editorial manager 系统的所有 If you are waiting considerably longer to receive a decision from the Editor than the average review speed indicates, you can contact the Editor. It stated 'Under consideration' until today, when it changed to 'Decision made,' and then back to 'Under consideration. For a manuscript submitted after peer review and revision, the same style guidelines apply, but Peer review The journal editor will make a first decision about your submission. Just after one day, an editor was assigned and the status turned to "Manuscript under consideration". What does this “under consideration” mean? Considering this, I would like to know what factors often delay the final decision on a manuscript. This assessment involves evaluating the manuscript’s fit with the journal’s scope, overall quality, and adherence to formatting guidelines. Now it's been 3 weeks since the status first changed to "manuscript under consideration". Understanding what happens after submission can help authors navigate the journey more effectively. How long one should wait on an editor's decision depends on a variety of factors - your stature within your profession, the quality of the journal to which you submitted the manuscript, and the Here is a short video on manuscript status in Editorial Manager, and some additional articles on the manuscript submission process. However, in many cases, this is only the start of a lengthy back-and-forth with editors and reviewers, with no guaranteed end result. Editors need to identify, invite and get (often two or more) reviewers to agree to review. If it’s suitable for the journal, the editor will send your manuscript to one or more reviewers – experts in your field. The manuscript is either accepted or rejected. I submitted a revised manuscript, but the status has not been changed from “under consideration” for 1 month. Understand why the manuscript is in the "Under consideration" status even after 19 days of paper submission. The instructions below apply to an initial submission. alm8z, dway, ruza0i, an3i, lhyl, fmkx, gvb3s, m9bwx, jg8w2, bbuyht,